Welcome to Penwell Insurance – We are Focused on You™!

We are an independent insurance agency with offices in Carmel, Cicero and Tipton Indiana.  Working with an independent agency provides flexibility in working with multiple insurance companies including Erie Insurance, Travelers Insurance, Safeco Insurance and Progressive Insurance to achieve your insurance goals and meet expectations. With insurance products to cover your home, automobile, life and business, let us provide a custom insurance review and recommend the insurance coverage options best suited for protecting your needs.  We are Focused on You™.

Join the Penwell Insurance Family

Learn more about how we can help protect your family or business investments by calling your preferred office or by filling out our online form.