Penwell Insurance and Erie Insurance are committed to maintaining a high standard of excellence and establishing a strong relationship of mutual trust and service to each of our clients. Penwell Insurance is located in Cicero, Indiana, and serves clients in Indiana and Illinois.
Penwell Insurance is service first agency and we believe our success centers on our ability to identify and satisfy our clients’ insurance needs.  Penwell Insurance looks to establish lasting relationships with our clients based on trust and our willingness to serve.  By offering auto, home, renters, boat, life, and commercial insurance products, Penwell Insurance can provide the coverage you need for whatever life brings your way.
"To provide our Policyholders with as near perfect protection, as near perfect service, as is humanly possible, and to do so at the lowest possible cost."
–H.O. Hirt, Cofounder

Companies We Represent

Penwell Insurance proudly
represents the following companies to meet your insurance needs."

Erie Insurance Group
www.erieinsurance.com

AIG
www.AIG.com

Bristol West
www.bristolwest.com

Progressive
www.driveinsurance.com

Contact Us

As your local ERIE Agent, we are committed to providing you with information that you need to make the right decision when it comes to protecting your family, home, auto and property.

Whether you need personal or business insurance protection, we can show you how to maximize your insurance program with discounts and cost saving features.

Call us to arrange an appointment today.