Skip to the content

Carmel Office: (317) 559-3022

Cicero Office: (317) 984-3300

Google Maps Logo (opens in new tab)Yelp Logo (opens in new tab)Facebook Logo (opens in new tab)Twitter Logo (opens in new tab)LinkedIn Logo (opens in new tab)Instagram Logo (opens in new tab)

Client Portal(opens in new tab)

Home Page (opens in new tab)

Services
- Auto, Home, and Personal Insurance
- Life Insurance
About
Community Connection Program
Support
Contact

Get Quote(opens in new tab)

Home > Cicero Office

Cicero Office

Penwell Insurance

30 South Peru Street
Cicero, Indiana 46034

Phone: (317) 984-3300

Fax: (317) 984-3338

Office Hours
Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: By Appointment

Get Directions (opens in new tab)

Send Us A Message

Name*
Company Name (If For a Business)
Email*
Phone*
Comments or Questions
Attach File(s)
Drop files here or

Max. file size: 59 MB.
CAPTCHA
Email
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Δ

Customer Reviews

They have been good for us, 3 houses, 4 cars and a large solar field.Brook E., Carmel, IN

5 stars!Jamie P., Carmel, IN

Awesome people and staff.ibrahim k., Carmel, IN

She always puts customers first with superior customer service...Sanam S., Carmel, IN

I have been extremely pleased with Penwell Insurance.Bill B., Carmel, IN

Great people to work with! Always on time with a good product.Raymond M., Carmel, IN

Super people, super service, highly knowledgable staff!Scott G., Carmel, IN

They go above and beyond.Penni G., Carmel, IN

I highly recommend Penwell Insurance and its team members!Debbie R., Carmel, IN

They have saved us quite a bit of money.Scott E., Carmel, IN

See All Reviews See All Reviews

Policy Service Center

For 24 hours customer service and claims contact information, please go to our online Policy Service Center.

Make a Payment(opens in new tab)

File A Claim(opens in new tab)

Policy Change Request(opens in new tab)

About

About Us
Meet Our Staff
Careers
Customer Reviews
Insurance Companies
Insurance Blog

Insurance

Auto, Home, and Personal Insurance
Life Insurance

Policy Service

Support
Online Billing & Payments
File A Claim
Policy Change Request
Annual Insurance Checklist

Carmel Office

Penwell Insurance

600 E Carmel Drive Suite 162
Carmel, Indiana 46032

Phone: (317) 559-3022

Fax: (317) 984-3338

Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: By Appointment

Google Maps Logo (opens in new tab)Yelp Logo (opens in new tab)Facebook Logo (opens in new tab)Twitter Logo (opens in new tab)LinkedIn Logo (opens in new tab)Instagram Logo (opens in new tab)

Cicero Office

Penwell Insurance

30 South Peru Street
Cicero, Indiana 46034

Phone: (317) 984-3300

Fax: (317) 984-3338

Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: By Appointment

Google Maps Logo (opens in new tab)Yelp Logo (opens in new tab)

Penwell Insurance provides car insurance, home insurance, life insurance, commercial auto insurance, and business insurance to all of Indiana and Illinois, including Carmel, Cicero, Fishers, and Hamilton County.

© Copyright 2023, Penwell Insurance | Privacy Statement | Accessibility Statement | Login

Websites for Insurance(opens in new tab)

See How Our Independent Insurance Agency Benefits You
See How Our Independent Insurance Agency Benefits You
Get a Quote
Erie Insurance J.D. Power Award for Home Insurance Claims
Erie Insurance is #1 in Customer Satisfaction with the Home Insurance Claims Experience
Disclaimer: For J.D. Power 2023 award information, visit jdpower.com/awards
September is Life Insurance Awareness Month.
It’s the perfect time to remind ourselves to plan ahead for the ones we love.
Get Started